when you are talking about milk perhaps need to just look at what it actually is ...

 

http://milkfacts.info/Milk%20Composition/Milk%20Composition%20Page.htm

 

so what part of milk shouldn't we be consuming....

Sorry but you lost me there too. So milk is fed to babies alright. Why should it bad for us other than the lactose intolerance thing? I have already acknowledged that aspect.

And the science reference wasn't made to your comments.

Links to heart disease, cancer, diabetes...

http://www.pcrm.org/health/diets/vegdiets/health-concerns-about-dairy-products

http://www.nutritionmd.org/nutrition_tips/nutrition_tips_understand_foods/dairy.html

http://www.pcrm.org/health/health-topics/milk-and-prostate-cancer-the-evidence-mounts

I don't want to argue with you on this topic.

Fair enough, we each have our own views about milk.

My 'logic' is straight! And that 'logic' is simple, my angle is that cows milk is designed for baby cows and 'not' for 'humans'!

Everyone can argue as much as they like.

Nail meet hammer

when you are talking about milk perhaps need to just look at what it actually is ...

http://milkfacts.info/Milk%20Composition/Milk%20Composition%20Page.htm

so what part of milk shouldn't we be consuming....

For me it's the protein (caesin) that makes me crook

For me it's the protein (caesin) that makes me crook

 

 

am not talking about individual intolerance. am trying to understand in the discussion here on what is it in the composition thats being suggested shouldn't be consumed by humans.

Links to heart disease, cancer, diabetes...

http://www.pcrm.org/health/diets/vegdiets/health-concerns-about-dairy-products

http://www.nutritionmd.org/nutrition_tips/nutrition_tips_understand_foods/dairy.html

http://www.pcrm.org/health/health-topics/milk-and-prostate-cancer-the-evidence-mounts

Now that's something I get! Makes so much more sense that way. Thanks.

There are things I don't necessarily agree with in the articles. But at least they offer some useful information to consider.

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

am not talking about individual intolerance. am trying to understand in the discussion here what is it in the composition thats being suggested shouldn't be consumed by humans.

Yeah, I could only offer my experience. FWIW that's why some people are able to drink A2 milk and not other types, it has a different protein.

But also, FWIW, any food that causes me do produce gas that would strip wallpaper and give me the ability to crap through the eye of a needle can't be good for me

Edited April 16, 20169 yr by caddisgeek

when you are talking about milk perhaps need to just look at what it actually is ...

 

http://milkfacts.info/Milk%20Composition/Milk%20Composition%20Page.htm

 

so what part of milk shouldn't we be consuming....

 

The WHOLE lot!

 

 what is it in the composition thats being suggested shouldn't be consumed by humans.

 

It is 'produced' by 'mother cows' for 'baby cows' !

 

Anything produced for 'another animal' would 'logically' NOT be 'designed' for 'any' other animal or being!

Links to heart disease, cancer, diabetes...

http://www.pcrm.org/health/diets/vegdiets/health-concerns-about-dairy-products

http://www.nutritionmd.org/nutrition_tips/nutrition_tips_understand_foods/dairy.html

http://www.pcrm.org/health/health-topics/milk-and-prostate-cancer-the-evidence-mounts

 

 

except as mentioned earlier most things if we consume in excess...depending on whom you talk to .... will end up causing these things.....

 

I also dont buy into "links" these things seem to change like the wind....one moment some study is saying something is bad for you...next moment some study says actually its very good for you.

 

even alcohol falls in the same category...

 

probably about only thing that wont is water  

Yeah, I could only offer my experience. FWIW that's why some people are able to drink A2 milk and not other types, it has a different protein.

 

having seen research on that ... its bit like the gluten free thing...only very small proportion are truly gluten intolerant...however as they state "gluten free" has a halo around it...which draws a lot of people whether they are actually gluten intolerant or not ! 

 

ps as declaration I've spent some years working in dairy as with food producers making non gluten free and gluten free products.

except as mentioned earlier most things if we consume in excess...depending on whom you talk to .... will end up causing these things.....

I also dont buy into "links" these things seem to change like the wind....one moment some study is saying something is bad for you...next moment some study says actually its very good for you.

even alcohol falls in the same category...

probably about only thing that wont is water

Hah that is so right.

Drink enough water and that'll kill you too

The WHOLE lot!

 

 

It is 'produced' by 'mother cows' for 'baby cows' !

 

Anything produced for 'another animal' would 'logically' NOT be 'designed' for 'any' other animal or being!

 

 

vitamins and minerals are not good for you ?

 

sorry no. buzzzzt ....wrong answer....

 

perhaps need to click on the link and read it to answer

Drink enough water and that'll kill you too

 

 

only if you want to breathe it  

 

not sure have read about anyone trying kill themselves with drinking water hehe

The WHOLE lot!

It is 'produced' by 'mother cows' for 'baby cows' !

Anything produced for 'another animal' would 'logically' NOT be 'designed' for 'any' other animal or being!

I can no longer tell whether you're talking evolution or just plain religious,

only if you want to breathe it

not sure have read about anyone trying kill themselves with drinking water hehe

It's called water intoxication, causes electrolyte imbalance and swelling of the brain

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_intoxication

It's called water intoxication, causes electrolyte imbalance and swelling of the brain

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_intoxication

 

 

flippin heck ! given body can dispense 0.8-1L a water per hour and need to exceed that for the condition your looking at consuming more than 24 L water a day ! I struggle to get a couple of litres into me a day  

 

yep good example of things in excess I guess ! hehe

I can no longer tell whether you're talking evolution or just plain religious,

 

I am talking 'common sense' !

 

Nothing more, nothing less!

 

Can you think about 'why' COWS produce 'milk'?

 

OK I'll answer for you.....It's for 'baby cows'!

 

Is that not clear enough?

 

I've got a question. Give me a substantial reason why 'humans' should consume an 'animals' product  DESIGNED 'for animals'?

Drink enough water and that'll kill you too

 

Yep, too much of 'anything' will kill you!

 

Conversely, alcohol and many other 'poisons' are OK....in 'moderation'!

 

Just saying......!

Just found lactose free ice cream yay

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Just found lactose free ice cream yay

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

You can buy A2 ice cream as well

You can buy A2 ice cream as well

Seen them. They're lactose free too?

No, they don't have the protein caesin it, a lot of people are intolerant of that as well

Dairy is making me fat!, must cut right back while I can still reach the keyboard